Love at First Bite Cookie Skillet

A warm, gooey cookie skillet with peanut butter & jelly flavor, Valentine’s sugar cookies, and the best toppings!

Love at First Bite Cookie Skillet is the kind of dessert that instantly feels like Valentine’s Day. Warm peanut butter and jelly cookie dough and sweet sugar cookies bake together in one cozy skillet, then get topped with ice cream, sprinkles, and Valentine’s M&M’s Peanuts. It’s the perfect shareable treat for your true love, your best girlfriends, or a fun date night with your kids.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• Warm, gooey cookie skillet that feels extra festive for Valentine’s Day
• Peanut butter and jelly cookie dough adds a fun, nostalgic twist
• Heart-design sugar cookies make it instantly themed and cute
• Baked in one skillet for easy prep and minimal cleanup
• Perfect for sharing with your partner, friends, or kids
• Great for Galentine’s Day, family movie night, or a cozy date night
• Topped with ice cream, sprinkles, and Valentine’s M&M’s Peanuts 
• Easy to customize with your favorite toppings

Ingredient Notes

• EatPastry PB&J Place & Bake Cookie Dough: This is the base of the skillet and gives that classic peanut butter and jelly flavor. Let it sit at room temperature so it presses easily into the pan.
• Pillsbury Ready-to-Bake Hearts Shape Sugar Cookie Dough: These add the Valentine’s Day look and a sweet sugar cookie contrast to the PB&J flavor. You’ll only need about three-quarters of the package.
• Vanilla Ice Cream: A classic topping that melts into the warm cookies and makes every bite extra indulgent.
• Valentine’s Sprinkles: Use any pink, red, or heart-shaped sprinkles to keep the theme fun and festive.
• Valentine’s M&M’s Peanuts: Crushing them adds crunch, color, and a little salty-sweet balance to the skillet.
• Nonstick Spray: Helps prevent sticking and makes serving easier straight from the skillet.

Quick Prep Notes

Do I need to use an oven-safe skillet?
Yes. Make sure your skillet is oven-safe up to 350°F. Cast iron or heavy metal skillets work best for even baking.

Should the cookie dough be room temperature?
Yes. Let both doughs sit out for about 10–15 minutes so they’re easier to press and break apart.

How do I know when the skillet is done?
The edges should be golden and the center just set. It will continue to firm up slightly as it rests.

Print

FAQ

Can I use a different cookie dough flavor?
Absolutely. Peanut butter, chocolate chip, or sugar cookie dough all work well if you can’t find the PB&J version.

Can I bake this in a regular pan instead of a skillet?
Yes. An 8- or 9-inch round or square pan works just fine. Just line it with parchment for easy removal.

How should I store leftovers?
Cover and store in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. Reheat in the microwave for a warm, gooey texture.

Can I add more toppings?
Yes. Chocolate drizzle, strawberries, whipped cream, or extra candy all make great additions.

Is this recipe kid-friendly?
Definitely. It’s a fun, shareable dessert that works perfectly for family nights, Valentine’s parties, or Galentine’s fun.

Sprinkle of Fun

Make this the sweet centerpiece of your Galentine’s Day night. Throw on your favorite rom-com, pop some bubbly or pink lemonade, and let everyone grab a spoon straight from the skillet. Pajamas encouraged, laughter required, and extra sprinkles always welcome. It’s the kind of dessert that turns a simple hangout into a full-on girls’ night tradition.